» Sign-In
Not all policies are equal - see how the plans measure up.
Not all policies are equal - see how the plans measure up.
See the difference
When it comes to pet insurance, it's important to do your research as the coverage from different providers varies. The range of options, extra add-ons, and exclusions can make it difficult to compare plans.
Enroll TodayThe easy-to-understand Healthy Paws plan covers all new accidents and illnesses without any annual or lifetime caps on payouts.
| Consideration | Healthy Paws | Pumpkin |
|---|---|---|
| No payout caps on any plans |
 |
 |
| Alternative care and genetic conditions coverage included in all plans |
|
|
| Reimbursement method based on the vet bill (not on a benefit schedule) |
|
|
| Annual deductible (not per condition) |
|
|
| Consumers Advocate rating (Consumers Advocate.org)* |
4.9 | 4.0 |
Included
Not included or some exclusions
Included
Not included or some exclusions
Customer Reviews
- Pumpkin's annual payouts range from $10,000 to unlimited for dogs and $7,000 to unlimited for cats. With a pet insurance plan from Healthy Paws, there are never limits on payouts per claim, per year, or for the lifetime of the policy.
- While Pumpkin is a newcomer to the pet insurance market (as of 2019), Healthy Paws has more than 10 years of experience and has insured over 550,000 pets and counting. Healthy Paws closed an average of over 116,000 claims per month in 2023.
- Don't just take our word for it - read reviews on third party pet insurance review websites and you'll see that Healthy Paws receives high customer ratings. Pumpkin is new to the market as of 2019 and has few customer reviews.
Reasons to consider Pumpkin: Healthy Paws does not enroll pets aged 14 or older. Pumpkin Pet Insurance has no upper age limits on insurable pets and may be a good choice for those looking for a new plan with pets older than 13. Pumpkin also covers exam fees related to an accident or illness, dental illness and care for behavioral issues, and customers can pay more for a wellness plan.
A highly rated plan with great customer care and coverage that never has caps on claim payouts annually or for the lifetime of the policy.
With an easy-to-understand plan and team of vet techs, pet parents, and compassionate customer care specialists, you can relax knowing that we'll be here to help you get your pet back on their paws.
